Aug 19 2010
‘The Dead. The Orphans. The Homeless.’
Shortly before 4 a.m. today local time, the last soldiers of the 4th Stryker Brigade, 2nd Infantry
Division crossed the border into Kuwait from Iraq. Seven years and five months after this same unit
participated in the invasion that deposed Saddam Hussein, the last American combat brigade had
left the country.
I’m grateful for those who serve in the military. I’m also reminded of the George McGovern quote:
I’m fed up to the ears with old men dreaming up wars for young men to die in.
The fact that 50,000 Americans and tens of thousands of private contractors will remain in Iraq
for some time to come (indefinitely? Think of Korea, Germany, Japan, etc., to say nothing of
Afghanistan) is, I guess, a difference with a distinction. Those remaining behind won’t be combat
soldiers first and foremost, although they will be in danger of attack and they will accompany Iraqi
soldiers on missions when requested.
A larger question is, what did we accomplish at what cost? Iraq was hell under Saddam Hussein. Iraq is anarchy after Saddam Hussein - an anarchy that oil companies and other profiteers are all too eager to exploit.
And the cost?
4,415 brave American soldiers dead, as of Wednesday. More than 32,000 seriously wounded. More
than 9,000 Iraqi military and police dead. 136 journalists, 51 media support workers and 94 foreign
aid workers killed. Well over 100,000 Iraqi civilian deaths, although the number varies so widely we
may never know how many died.
That’s some cost.
I’ll close with Gandhi:
What difference does it make to the dead, the orphans, and the homeless, whether
the mad destruction is wrought under the name of totalitarianism or the holy name
of liberty and democracy?
David Elliot is the Communications Director at USAction




